← All Intel

AnalysisMSFTAAPLAMZN

Senate Judiciary Examines Risk of Big Tech’s Vulnerabilities from China

In November 2024, the Senate Judiciary Committee held a hearing, “Big Hacks & Big Tech: China’s Cybersecurity Threat,” that underscored the risks to American security created by Big Tech’s cozy relationship with China. Tech Integrity Project commends the Committee for creating a bipartisan venue to examine this important issue. Here are some highlights.

Both parties see Big Tech trading American security for profit

Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) said:

“Even as Chinese companies undermine our national security, American ones often do the same. China has used economic coercion to enlist American companies for its own agenda. And we have given them a free pass far too often. Companies like Apple have acted as partners of the Chinese government to censor ideas and information in China. They blocked independent media, and they’ve helped the CCP crackdown on dissent, human rights and democratic values. But also our national and economic security are at stake as a result of China’s leverage, its economic leverage, and these conflicts of interest involving American companies.”

Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) said:

“We face with China, a peer competitor of a kind that we frankly haven’t seen in any of our lifetimes. And I hope it’s also a wake-up call for these American corporations that, for too long, had been willing to sell out American jobs and America’s security interest in order to make a quick buck and, in so doing, have threatened all of us.”

Big Tech is invested in, and dependent on, China

Big Tech relies on China for manufacturing and sales. Senators asked what risks that creates for America. Hawley put the question to Isaac Stone Fish, CEO of Strategy Risks:

“…We’ve got these companies, Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Tesla, hugely, hugely invested in China and hugely dependent on China. And it would be one thing if they were run-of-the-mill, no-name companies.

“But Apple, and Amazon, Microsoft, these are arguably—each of those three are—monopoly size companies that have significant control of vast sections of our consumer economy. So I guess my question is, how concerned should we be that 80% of Apple suppliers have a base in China, 95% of Apple’s key consumer products are manufactured in China, a third of Amazon’s suppliers are in China … Microsoft’s China-based research lab produces 10% of the company’s research output? Those are massive numbers. Should we be concerned about this? Or is this not relevant? I mean, are we panicking unnecessarily?”

Stone Fish replied:

“Thank you for bringing these issues up. I think this is incredibly important. And I think there’s this perception in DC that, ‘oh, everyone’s talking about China.’ We’re talking about it too much.

“I don’t think we’re talking about this nearly enough. I am really appreciative that you brought up the potential for a Chinese invasion of Taiwan and a war with Taiwan. It’s our very strong belief that the businesses you mentioned have constantly underpriced the risk of a Chinese invasion of Taiwan, and they’ve long underpriced the risk of their very heavy China exposure. There’s massive national security implications of the figures that you just described.

“And I think U.S. government agencies need to be really aware of the various different interests and influences inside these corporations. You know, we’re in an era of shareholder capitalism. And if it’s in Apple’s best financial interest to double down on China, where does that leave us?

“And where does it leave Apple consumers who’s using an Apple laptop right here, but also the U.S. government? I think this is especially the case with Microsoft and the U.S. government’s relationship with Microsoft. And understanding that the depth of Microsoft’s entanglement with China and with the Chinese Communist Party poses very real supply chain and security risks. And these are things that big U.S. companies absolutely need to disclose.”

Blumenthal added:

“Apple complies with China’s censorship and surveillance demands, because 20% of its sales, and 80% of its suppliers are based in China. When forced to choose between American security and hugely profitable access to the Chinese market, Americans may doubt that SpaceX, Mr. Musk, Tim Cook, and other technology leaders will side with America.”

Watch the hearing

Get TIP intelligence in your inbox.

Subscribe to Briefings →